Restaurants

Paesano's Pizza Spring Mills

4.5 362 reviews Closed 5801 Williamsport Pike Suite 100, Martinsburg, WV 25404, United States

Discover this place

If you're hunting for an exceptional pizza experience in Martinsburg, look no further than Paesano's Pizza Spring Mills. Tucked away at 5801 Williamsport Pike Suite 100, this gem is quickly becoming the local favorite, as evidenced by rave reviews from satisfied customers.

Jennifer Jade, for instance, a New Jersey native, sings praises for their cheese pizza, declaring it her top choice after trying various places. Meanwhile, Tyler T highlights the versatility with both New York and Sicilian styles, recommending a mouth-watering combination of toppings that turned his pizza into a delicious supreme. Not to mention, Tj Moore appreciates the friendly service in a clean setting, perfect for those looking to escape fast food.

Jordan's experience further exemplifies their commitment to great food at reasonable prices. Their medium cheese pepperoni pizza coupled with hot wings left a lasting impression—remarkably flavorful and generous portions.

Whether you're stopping in for a quick pick-up or enjoying a cozy delivery, Paesano's Pizza stands out for its quality, taste, and affordability. It's a must-try for any pizza lover!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Paesano's Pizza Spring Mills before visiting.

Reviews for Paesano's Pizza Spring Mills

4.5

362 reviews

100%

18%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 362 reviews

Paesano's Pizza Spring Mills is widely appreciated for its authentic New York and Sicilian-style pizzas that resonate well with pizza enthusiasts seeking quality and traditional flavors. Customers frequently commend the fresh ingredients, flavorful sauces, and satisfying crusts, often highlighting the generous portion sizes. The restaurant’s reliable and timely delivery service is noted for maintaining food quality and temperature, enhancing the overall dining experience. Additionally, the establishment is praised for its welcoming atmosphere, clean environment, and convenient parking, appealing to both dine-in and takeout patrons. Competitive pricing and varied menu options, including popular hot wings, further contribute to Paesano's strong reputation as a preferred local pizza destination.

Jennifer Jade

Jun 21, 2025

I am from Jersey and ever since moving to Maryland, I haven’t been able to find a good pizza comparison. Luckily, I was in the area and ordered just a plain cheese. Definitely my favorite spot out of all the places I have tried!

Tyler T

Jun 15, 2025

Definitely a must try pizza restaurant! They have NY Style as well as Sicilian Style pizzas. We got the New York style and added pepperoni, onion, green pepper and mushroom. It was kinda like a supreme and tasted delicious. Easy pickup and fresh results, will definitely be back to try more!

Tj Moore

May 24, 2025

great people behind the counter and food is always great. nice quiet stop if you want to avoid fast food. it's clean and has great parking.

Shirley Wolf

May 13, 2025

We use delivery often. Always pleasant, on time and the food is hot.

Jordan

Apr 30, 2025

Me and my GF walked over to try this place out because it just opened up. We ordered a medium 14” cheese pepperoni pizza and 10 Hot wings for only 24. I thought that was a really good price. But first of all, those wings were sooo good and hot, I hate I had to share them. Also the pizza was incredible, big slices, delicious sauce, and nice crunchy crust NY style of course. Honestly the medium is pretty big for 2 people but I don’t mind the left over slices. Try this place out, best pizza i’ve had in this area that’s for sure.

JR “Wyldman” Wyldman

Apr 28, 2025

One of my favorite places to go for a steak and cheese Sub their pizza and chicken bakes are excellent as well. Stromboli are

Amelia Jones

Apr 27, 2025

My family and I usually get a Sicilian pizza. Every single one that I've had from here has been wonderful. The spaghetti was great. I also love the tiramisu. I have tried the steak and cheese and that was good. Honestly I have no complaints. The place is clean and the food is done quickly. Best pizza place in Spring Mills by far! My go to place every pizza night.

SGTN00BIAN

Mar 26, 2025

Was kind of a last minute call to go here, it was Sunday and I wasn't feeling normal pizza chains so, I just look up pizza near me and this popped up. I've lived around the area for years and have never been so we tried it and it was great. The staff was nice and the food came out hot and it tasted great. Got a Pep and Chz pizza and it was good and those garlic rolls in the picture were very good and I'm glad I didn't just do my normal mozzarella sticks as an appetizer.